In July 2021, Far Afield came to market at $74 million. The estate at 670 Hot Springs Road is a seven-bedroom house of about 20,000 square feet that Francis T. Underhill designed in 1917, set on 10.5 acres. Over the next five years the asking price was cut twice, to $59.9 million, and then raised to $60 million. In October 2026 it closed at $56.1 million, according to Siteline Santa Barbara's sales roundup of October 18. That was the highest home sale on the South Coast in October, according to the Santa Barbara Association of REALTORS October 2026 MLS report.
Measured against the final ask, the buyer paid about 93.5 percent. Measured against the first ask, the buyer paid about 76 percent. Both numbers describe the same sale. For anyone weighing Montecito against Bel-Air, Brentwood or the Palisades this season, the second number is the more useful one. Montecito's top tier spent 2026 clearing estates that had waited a long time for a buyer, and each one closed where the buyers of 2026 put it. A median for 93108 records only the midpoint of the prices that closed. The list history of each house shows how it got there.
Three estates, three list histories
Far Afield was the largest of these sales, but two other estates on the Golden Quadrangle and San Ysidro side of town went the same way earlier in the year.
Edhat reported that Casamar, a Mediterranean-style residence on about 2.12 acres at 1502 E. Mountain Drive, sold for $19.5 million on September 8, 2026, five days after going pending. It had asked $23.5 million in 2023 and $21.9 million in 2024, and both listings were withdrawn. It came back in June 2026 at $21.9 million. It last sold in March 2005 for $11.75 million.
Two weeks earlier, Edhat covered the sale of 818 San Ysidro Lane, a 1.02-acre Spanish Revival property that architect Jon Sorrell designed in the tradition of George Washington Smith. It was listed at $12 million in May, cut to $10.95 million in June, and sold on August 25, 2026 for $10.3 million, or $1,988 per square foot. It last sold for $5 million in 2012.
| Estate | First asking price | Final asking price | Sale price | Share of first ask | Share of final ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Far Afield, 670 Hot Springs Rd | $74M, July 2021 | $60M | $56.1M, Oct. 2026 | about 76% | about 94% |
| Casamar, 1502 E. Mountain Dr | $23.5M, 2023 | $21.9M, June 2026 | $19.5M, Sept. 8, 2026 | about 83% | about 89% |
| 818 San Ysidro Lane | $12M, May 2026 | $10.95M, June 2026 | $10.3M, Aug. 25, 2026 | about 86% | about 94% |
Casamar sold for about two-thirds more than its 2005 price, and San Ysidro Lane for roughly double its 2012 price. All three sold for less than its first ask, and the longer a house had been listed, the further the sale landed below that first number. San Ysidro Lane took one cut and closed within about three months of its first listing. Casamar went through three listing periods across four years. Far Afield went through five years of changing asks. The final ask was a reasonable guide to the sale price in all three cases. The first ask was not.
For a sense of scale, the Montecito Journal's 2025 year in review reported that Montecito's highest sale of 2025 was 700 Picacho Lane at $60 million. So the top of the market has held in the $56 million to $60 million range across two years. What has changed is how long the biggest estates take to reach a sale and how far they travel from their opening price.
The negotiating moved to the table
The Santa Barbara Association of REALTORS publishes its MLS figures for the South Coast as a whole, districts 05 through 35, so the numbers below cover Montecito together with Santa Barbara, Hope Ranch and the rest of the coast. Even so, they show where the discount happened this fall.
In October 2026, South Coast single-family and PUD sales closed at 92.77 percent of their final list price and 91.23 percent of their original list price. In October 2025 the same figures were 94.55 percent and 88.99 percent. A year ago, most of the gap between the opening price and the sale price was closed by cuts made while the house was on the market. The difference between the two ratios was about 5.6 points. This October that difference was about 1.5 points. Sellers this year opened closer to the eventual price, and more of the remaining discount was settled between the parties at the end.
The top price band shows the same thing in days on market. In October, the 17 sales listed at $5 million or more took an average of 61 days to sell from their current listing. Measured continuously across relistings, they took 131 days. Across the whole market, the October average was 36 days, or 58 days continuously. When the continuous count runs more than twice the current one, many of those houses have been withdrawn and listed again. Casamar is an example. A day-on-market figure taken from a single listing can understate how long a house has been for sale.
The September report recorded the other outcome. Fourteen South Coast listings expired that month without selling. Their average asking price was $13,134,500, and they had been listed for an average of 170 days. Over the same month, the 87 homes that did sell had an average price of $3,408,230. At the top of the market, the houses that went unsold were mostly the expensive ones.
Why the median points the wrong way
Through September 2026, South Coast home sales rose 8.5 percent from a year earlier, to 769. Over the same period the median sale price fell 11.4 percent, to $2,115,000. The Santa Barbara Independent's October 29 analysis explains most of that drop by what sold. In the twelve months ending September 30, 2026, sales under $2 million rose from 34 percent of transactions to 46 percent, and sales above $5 million fell from 20 percent to 16 percent. The Independent also reported that homes above $5 million still accounted for 48 percent of dollar volume. The Independent described the market as becoming "increasingly selective rather than declining uniformly."
The SBAOR report also breaks out the figures without Montecito and Hope Ranch. On that basis the year-to-date median through September fell 6 percent and the average sale price fell 1.8 percent. With both enclaves included, the average fell 3.5 percent. Including Montecito and Hope Ranch roughly doubles the drop in the average. That fits what the three estates above show. The softness was at the top and in long-listed homes, and it shows up in individual sales well before it shows up in a regional median.
Below the estates, 93108 kept moving
The rest of Montecito did not stall. Writing in the Montecito Journal on September 1, Mark Ashton Hunt counted 22 homes sold in 93108 through the MLS over the previous six weeks or so. Four sold above $10 million and five sold around $7 million. More than 20 properties were in escrow, compared with about 15 in a typical month over the prior year. He also reported inventory up about 15 percent between early July and August 22, the largest one-month increase in more than a year. Some homes that sold a year or two earlier were back on the market at similar or lower prices.
Hunt's column also sketched the price bands. Condos around Coast Village Road and the beach run from about $1.8 million to above $6 million. Cottages, starter homes and "upgradeable homes" fall roughly between $2.5 million and $6 million. Estates start above $10 million. If you have followed the restaurant openings along Coast Village Road this summer, the lower band is the part of the market closest to that village life. The upper band is where the three estate sales above took place.
The Independent's account of homes that sell quickly matches Hunt's numbers. Updated, well-priced homes in desirable locations still drew multiple offers and sold above asking. Homes that needed substantial work or opened at an ambitious price tended to sit and take reductions. Both groups exist in Montecito, and they sell at different speeds.
Reading a Montecito listing from Los Angeles
For a buyer comparing Montecito with the Westside, the practical step is to read each listing as a timeline. Start with when the house first came to market and at what price, whether it was withdrawn and relisted, and how many continuous days it has been for sale. Casamar's current listing in June 2026 showed about three months on market. Its full history showed four years. Far Afield's $60 million final ask looked firm on its own. Its $74 million first ask showed how far the price had already moved.
Pay the most attention to the relistings Hunt described, homes that sold a year or two ago and are back at or below their earlier price. Those houses have a recent sale on record to price against, which is rare for a Montecito estate. For newly listed, updated homes in the cottage and upgradeable band, the Independent's reporting suggests that buyers who wait for a cut may lose the house to another offer.
Our Montecito neighborhood page covers the village itself. Our note on how serious buyers find off-market listings in Los Angeles covers properties that never get a public list history at all.
Frequently asked questions
Did Montecito home values fall 11 percent in 2026? No regional figure supports that. The 11.4 percent drop in the South Coast median through September 2026 mostly reflects more sales under $2 million and fewer above $5 million, according to the Santa Barbara Independent. Over the same period the region's average sale price fell 3.5 percent.
What was the largest Montecito sale of 2026? Among the sales in the public record we cite, it was Far Afield at 670 Hot Springs Road, which closed at $56.1 million in October 2026. That price is below the $60 million sale of 700 Picacho Lane, the top sale of 2025 as reported by the Montecito Journal.
How much room is there between asking and sale price right now? In October 2026, South Coast homes closed at 92.77 percent of final list price on average. The three estate sales above closed at roughly 89 to 94 percent of their final asks and 76 to 86 percent of their first asks.
If you are weighing a Montecito estate against a Westside one, the list history of each house is the place to start, and it is often the hardest part to find. For a full timeline of any 93108 property you are considering, along with a read on where it is likely to trade, request a private market consultation with Jonathan Ruiz.